MIKAEL SILVESTRE says Amandou Onana is not a player Manchester United should be chasing as he is very similar to Scott McTominay.
Erik ten Hag is considering a shock move to sign the Everton midfielder as transfer talks with Fiorentina have stalled for Sofiyan Amrabat.
But this has raised questions on whether the 21-year-old is the right choice for a move to Old Trafford.
The ex-Man Utd ace said to betting expert: "I understand why, profile-wise, Amadou Onana is a player they are looking for.
"But when you have Scott McTominay, I don’t see what Onana will add to United if you want to step up and challenge for the title.
“He’s not a player United should be chasing.
READ MORE MAN UTD
Van de Beek offered new Man Utd escape route but Ten Hag won’t be impressed
Win a VW Campervan + £1k or £47,500 cash from just 89p with our discount code
“Physically, he and McTominay have the same profile, and it’s not an upgrade.
"So I don’t think it makes sense unless you’re looking for backup.”
Onana was one of Everton's top performers during a troublesome campaign last season.
He made 33 appearances for the club as they narrowly avoided relegation to the Championship.
Most read in Football
Man Utd WILL welcome Mason Greenwood back into the fold next week
Chelsea 'put Lewis Hall up for sale for £30m' but it's a bitter Newcastle blow
Four reasons why Lionesses will seal World Cup glory including Spain turmoil
Sky Sports legend confirms new job following shock Soccer Saturday exit
FREE BETS AND SIGN UP DEALS – BEST NEW CUSTOMER OFFERS
Everton could demand up to £50m to let the Belgian international leave, having signed Onana for £33m last summer.
But another former Man Utd legend has also come out to say similar things about the Red Devils' attraction to the youngster.
Rio Ferdinand said Onana could end up being another Maroouana Fellaini- and does not fit Ten Hag's style of play.
However, the Man Utd boss remains keen to further bolster his midfield this summer, having already landed Mason Mount in a £60million deal from Chelsea.
United midfielder Fred has completed a move to Fenerbahce ahead of his £13m move, while Donny van de Beek has been linked with Real Sociedad.
Silvestre also said Bayern Munich's Benjamin Pavard would be the perfect fit for Ten Hag's side.
He said: " If Harry Maguire goes, he (Benjamin Pavard) can play in a three-man defence or a four-man defence as well as right back, so he brings versatility.
“Steady defender. Similar to Victor Lindelof profile-wise.
"Good on the ball and reads situations.
"Not necessarily fast or strong, but reads the game.
Read More on The Sun
Olympic swimmer tragically found dead by her four-year-old daughter
Britney Spears breaks her silence after husband files for divorce
“He could help the manager to change the system at the back when needed.”
The Red Devils' deal to sign Pavard has been held up by the collapse of Harry Maguire's sale to West Ham.
MAN UTD NEWS LIVE: Stay up to date with all the latest takeover and transfer news from Old Trafford
Source: Read Full Article